Artists Outside London ‘Underrepresented on Mercury Prize Shortlist,’ Say Former Nominees

The Mercury Prize has long been regarded as one of the UK’s most prestigious music awards — a benchmark of artistic achievement and innovation. But despite its reputation for celebrating diversity and creativity, a growing number of former nominees argue that the awards have failed to represent artists from outside London fairly.

According to new data compiled by The Guardian, there is a stark imbalance in regional representation: over the prize’s 34-year history, there have been 130 more nominees from London than from the next most shortlisted region. The numbers paint a picture of an award heavily tilted toward the capital, raising questions about access, visibility, and the structural barriers facing musicians across the rest of the UK.

A Landmark Ceremony Beyond the Capital

This year’s Mercury Prize ceremony, which takes place on Thursday night in Newcastle, marks a significant first — it’s the first time in the award’s history that the event is being held outside London. The decision was hailed as a symbolic step toward acknowledging the strength of the UK’s regional music scenes.

Music critic Laura Snapes noted that the move “feels long overdue.” She added, “For decades, British music has thrived on local identity — from Manchester’s indie rock legacy to Bristol’s trip-hop roots — yet the Mercury Prize has rarely looked beyond London when it comes to celebrating that richness.”

The 2025 nominations have been described as the most regionally diverse ever, featuring artists from six English regions as well as Scotland, Wales, and Ireland. Acts such as Joesef (Glasgow), Adwaith (Carmarthen), and The Royston Club (Wrexham) join London-based frontrunners like Little Simz and The Last Dinner Party.

However, industry figures argue that a single diverse year cannot offset decades of metropolitan dominance.

The Capital Bias

Since the Mercury Prize was launched in 1992, it has sought to recognize the best British and Irish album of the year, regardless of genre or commercial success. Yet, data reveals that London artists have dominated the shortlist, often crowding out acts from regional scenes.

Between 2014 and 2023, every single winner came from London — a period that saw acclaimed victories for acts such as Skepta, Wolf Alice, Dave, and Arlo Parks. The streak was finally broken in 2024 when Leeds-based band English Teacher claimed the award, ending a decade-long run of capital-based winners.

Since 2010, only three winners have come from outside London: Alt-J from Leeds (2012), Sam Fender from North Shields (2020), and English Teacher in 2024.

Music journalist Ben Beaumont-Thomas pointed out that while London’s infrastructure — from recording studios to media exposure — gives its artists an advantage, the imbalance has grown starker in recent years as regional venues and labels struggle to survive.

“It’s not that the Mercury Prize deliberately excludes artists from elsewhere,” he said. “It’s that everything about how music is made, promoted, and distributed in the UK revolves around London. Artists from Liverpool or Glasgow can be just as innovative, but they’re fighting uphill battles to get the same attention.”

The Geography of Opportunity

The concentration of nominees in London reflects broader inequalities within the UK’s cultural landscape. Many artists outside the capital face challenges ranging from limited access to major studios and managers to fewer performance opportunities and less national media exposure.

A 2023 report by the Musicians’ Union found that over 60% of UK recording studios are based in London and the South East, while touring costs for independent artists have risen sharply since Brexit and the pandemic.

For regional musicians, the hurdles can be both logistical and psychological. Newcastle-based singer-songwriter Martha Hill, who was longlisted for the 2025 Mercury Prize, said:

“It’s amazing that the ceremony’s in Newcastle this year, but there’s still a sense that you need to ‘make it in London’ before anyone takes you seriously. There’s incredible talent all over the country — it just doesn’t get the same platform.”

Diversity Beyond Geography

While the 2025 shortlist has been praised for including a wider range of regions, it also stands out for its cultural and stylistic diversity. The nominees span a spectrum of genres, from grime and jazz to indie, folk, and experimental pop.

Critics have noted that regional diversity often brings sonic diversity, too. The inclusion of artists from Wales, Scotland, and the north of England introduces distinctive voices that reflect local influences and experiences.

Cultural analyst Dr. Helen Reddington, a senior lecturer in music production, said the Mercury Prize’s shift northward could help challenge entrenched industry biases. “Music scenes outside London are often more collaborative and community-driven,” she explained. “Bringing those artists into national recognition not only broadens the prize’s relevance but also revitalizes the cultural ecosystem.”

Can the Mercury Prize Evolve?

The Mercury Prize’s organizers have said that this year’s move to Newcastle is part of a broader plan to “celebrate creativity across the UK.” But questions remain over whether this will translate into lasting change.

Many in the industry argue that true regional equity will require more than a one-off event. Initiatives such as mentoring programs, funding for regional recording infrastructure, and partnerships with local media could help level the playing field.

London’s dominance, after all, is not unique to the Mercury Prize — it reflects a longstanding centralization of Britain’s creative industries. But as audiences and technologies evolve, there is growing pressure to recognize and support talent wherever it emerges.

For artists like Hill, the moment feels like both an opportunity and a challenge. “Holding the prize in Newcastle is huge,” she said. “But what matters is what comes next — whether we’ll keep seeing regional artists getting real recognition, or whether this is just a token gesture.”

As the 2025 ceremony approaches, the Mercury Prize finds itself at a crossroads. The event’s move beyond London signals an effort to reshape its legacy — but whether it can sustain that inclusivity in the years ahead remains to be seen.

‍