Daughters of man murdered in Michigan church forgive shooter in emotional letter

Grace Over Grief: Daughters of Michigan Church Shooting Victim Forgive Their Father's Killer

In a powerful act of compassion that has moved many across the country, the daughters of a man fatally shot inside a Michigan church have publicly forgiven the shooter. Their emotional open letter, released just days after the tragedy, offers a rare glimpse into the human capacity for grace—even in the face of devastating loss.

The shooting took place during a Sunday morning service at a small community church in Lansing, Michigan. The victim, 52-year-old Thomas “Tom” Reynolds, was a well-known member of the congregation and a beloved father of three. According to authorities, the suspect—identified as a 25-year-old local man—entered the church during the service and opened fire, fatally striking Reynolds before being subdued by worshippers and later taken into custody by police.

While the community continues to grapple with the shock and trauma of the event, it is the response from Reynolds' daughters that has captured national attention.

A Letter of Forgiveness

Just four days after their father’s murder, Emily, Sarah, and Grace Reynolds released an open letter addressed not to the public, but directly to their father’s killer. Shared by their family’s pastor and later posted online, the letter has gone viral for its striking message: forgiveness, not vengeance.

“We choose forgiveness, not because it’s easy, but because it’s what our father would have wanted,” the sisters wrote. “Hate will never heal our pain. Only love and mercy can do that.”

The letter goes on to describe their father as a man of deep faith who believed in second chances. He volunteered at local shelters, mentored at-risk youth, and often said that “every person is more than their worst moment.”

“You took him from us in a moment of violence, but you cannot take his legacy,” the letter continued. “He taught us to live with open hands and open hearts. Today, we live that truth by forgiving you.”

The Tragedy That Shook a Community

The shooting has left the Lansing community reeling. The small church, which typically draws fewer than 100 attendees on Sundays, has become a place of mourning, reflection, and resilience.

According to witnesses, the shooter entered quietly, sat near the back, and waited for the pastor to begin the sermon before opening fire. While the motive remains unclear, officials have ruled out terrorism and are exploring potential mental health factors. Investigators are working to determine whether the victim was targeted or if the attack was random.

In the days following the shooting, the church has held nightly vigils attended by hundreds, including residents from nearby towns. Flowers, candles, and handwritten notes now line the church’s front steps. Many community members have spoken out, not only about the pain of the loss but also about the power of the Reynolds daughters’ letter.

“Their words brought me to tears,” said Deacon Margaret Ellis, a longtime member of the church. “In a time when they had every right to be angry, they chose to show mercy. That’s the kind of strength only faith can bring.”

Faith in Action

Tom Reynolds was a man of conviction. Friends describe him as a quiet leader—someone who lived his faith rather than preaching it. He was known to bring food to shut-in neighbors, offer rides to recovering addicts, and speak kindly to strangers. His daughters say that he often reminded them, “You can’t control what others do, but you can always choose your response.”

That philosophy, they say, shaped their decision to forgive.

“Our forgiveness isn’t a free pass,” the letter clarified. “Justice must still be served. But we refuse to let bitterness take root in our hearts.”

The sisters’ words echo sentiments found in many faith traditions, where forgiveness is not only a virtue but also a command. From Christianity to Islam, from Buddhism to Judaism, forgiveness is often held up as the antidote to hatred and violence. Still, few manage to embody it so soon after personal tragedy.

The Shooter’s Fate

As the investigation continues, the suspect—whose name has not yet been released due to ongoing legal proceedings—has been charged with first-degree murder and multiple counts of felony firearm possession. His arraignment is scheduled for later this month.

Law enforcement officials have confirmed that the suspect has a prior history of mental health issues and encounters with police. He is currently undergoing a psychological evaluation to determine his competency to stand trial.

While the legal system moves forward, the Reynolds family is focused on healing.

A Legacy of Light

The Reynolds daughters are now working with church leaders to launch a community initiative in their father’s name. The program, called “Tom’s Table,” will provide meals and mentorship to local youth—continuing the work he loved most.

“Our father believed in lifting others up,” said Emily Reynolds during a vigil. “Through this tragedy, we will carry his mission forward. We will not let hate have the last word.”

The family has also set up a scholarship fund to support students pursuing careers in social work, counseling, and ministry—fields that reflect the heart of who Tom Reynolds was.

A Message to the Nation

As gun violence continues to plague American communities, the Reynolds family’s response stands as a counter-narrative. In a world where retribution often feels like the default response, their choice to forgive offers a different path—one marked by hope, healing, and humanity.

Their letter has since been shared by national leaders, religious organizations, and mental health advocates alike. Many see it as a beacon of light during a dark time.

In the end, the daughters of Tom Reynolds remind us all of an uncomfortable yet powerful truth: that forgiveness, though painful, is often the first step toward peace.

‍